Everyone hates the Mormons.
A few months ago, I made the mistake of commenting on a “Christianity vs. Mormonism” Facebook post. I don’t remember the topic or what I wrote, but apparently the algorithm interpreted this to mean that I wanted more of this type of content in my feed. I’ve long known about the attacks on Mormonism by mainstream Christians, but I had never witnessed it firsthand. And I certainly didn’t realize just how pervasive and rabid it is. Merely mentioning the word “Mormon” seems to trigger some reflexive, primal, Pavlovian response: “MORMONS AREN’T CHRISTIANS.” I now hear it or see it almost every day. I’ve thought a lot about it and tried to understand the psychological reasons or motivations behind it. I think it boils down to gatekeeping and boundary policing. Mainstream Christians view Mormonism as a heretical movement, and they are motivated to keep Mormonism out of the Christian tent. They are the host trying to keep out an invading species. In-group vs. out-group. So, they recite their “Mormons aren’t Christians” incantations to “other” the Latter-Day Saints. One of my best friends and former mission companions, who chairs the Department of Ancient Scripture at BYU, engages in a lot of interfaith dialogue. He once told me that mainstream Christians won’t give the Mormons a seat at the table, but they can’t even agree on the Trinity doctrine. Catholics, Protestants, Lutherans, Calvinists, Methodists, Seventh Day Adventists, and Baptists, despite their opposing and contradictory doctrines, can be considered “Christian,” but the new kid on the block cannot claim membership in their Christendom. In short, it’s a turf war. (Ken LaCorte, who runs the very excellent YouTube channel “Elephants in Rooms,” recently did a video on why Mormons are so disliked, despite the Church’s very obvious success. I highly recommend it.)
Equally alarming is the verbal abuse BYU football has faced over the last five years when playing on the road. Most notably, last year BYU played at the University of Cincinnati. Before the game, the Church delivered 27,000 lbs. of food to the university’s food bank—the single largest donation in the institution’s history. Local members, BYU fans, and missionaries unloaded the truck. During the game the next day, the Cincinnati fans chanted, “F— the Mormons.” Unfortunately, this isn’t an isolated incident. The Salt Lake Tribune reported this past October, “Since the start of last football season, there have been documented incidents of opposing fans chanting ‘F— the Mormons’ or other iterations at Arizona, Colorado, Cincinnati and Oklahoma State, resulting in public reprimands by the conference office and fines of $50,000 for Colorado and Oklahoma State.” After the article was written, it happened again when BYU played at the University of Central Florida on October 24, resulting in a $100,000 fine. It’s gotten so bad that the Big 12 conference has introduced new sportsmanship guidelines and penalties, including on-the-field penalties.
These attacks come directly from people who claim to be “Christians.” I put that in scare quotes because their behavior is frequently at odds with what one would expect from a self-professed follower of Jesus. These “Christians” are frequently vile, demeaning, derogatory, judgmental, hypocritical, and mean-spirited. They tend to operate from a position of presumed moral, scriptural, and spiritual authority. They assume that a belief the Bible provides immunity from any arguments or objections to their orthodoxy. The Bible is the sole arbiter of truth…because the Bible said so. The irony of it all is that they’re overwhelmingly biblically illiterate. They can cite verses but generally ignore context. Ask why you should accept Paul’s apostolic and visionary claims as truth, and they’ll mock you. Show them demonstrable contradictions in the Bible, and they’ll ignore you. It’s incredible to watch it happen in real time. The average Latter-Day Saint has more Christlike virtue in his or her pinkie finger than the average “Christian” has in his or her entire body.
Those who frequent my blog know I don’t formally affiliate with any LDS branches, but as someone whose history with Mormonism goes all the way back to Kirtland (my fifth great-grandfather, Alpheus Gifford, baptized Heber C. Kimball in 1832), I feel protective of the Latter-Day Saints. They are my family, my friends, my community, and my heritage. They are the best people I have ever known, and they have accomplished incredible things. I have no desire to tear down the Church or the LDS people. Quite the contrary. I want the Church to fulfill its promise and potential. I want it to be a force for good in the world. The Church was given a magnificent gift in the Book of Mormon, a gift that has been squandered. I want the Church to repent because the Brother of Jared’s record “shall not go forth unto the Gentiles (LDS) until the day that they shall repent of their iniquity and become clean before the Lord” (Ether 4:6). So, this post is as much for them as it is for anyone who professes a belief in the Book of Mormon. The Latter-Day Saints have every right to call themselves Christians and I won’t allow anyone to knowingly or unknowingly misrepresent the Book of Mormon. People are certainly free to disagree, but misrepresentation isn’t disagreement.
“MORMONS AREN’T CHRISTIANS”
If you should ever have a conversation or debate with a mainstream Christian about LDS doctrine, there is a 100% chance that they will quote at least one of the following. First, Deuteronomy 18:22: “When a prophet speaketh in the name of the LORD, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the LORD hath not spoken, but the prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him.” They call this the “prophet test.” If a prophecy fails, the person who uttered the prophecy is a false prophet. Several of Joseph’s prophecies demonstrable failed, such as a temple being built in Independence “in this generation” (D&C 84) and the promise of “wealth pertaining gold and silver” in Salem, Massachusetts (D&C 111). Unsurprisingly, they won’t hold the Hebrew prophets to the same standard. Paul Sanders from the Protestant Theological University wrote,
“Ezekiel’s prophecies against Tyre take up a lot of space (26:1–28:19), almost as much as those against Egypt (29:1–32:32). They describe the city’s downfall, including all its wealth. Two lamentations even portray Tyre’s glory as already a thing of the past (27:1–36; 28:11–19) …Around 150 years ago, the renowned Old Testament scholar Abraham Kuenen, a professor in Leiden, already highlighted that the predicted destruction of Tyre by Nebuchadnezzar never occurred. Kuenen was quite keen on finding examples of unfulfilled prophecies. Still, he had a valid point in the case of Ezekiel 26.”
There are likewise problems with Ezekiel 29-30 and the pronouncements against Egypt that never came to be. Christian scholars come up with creative ways to work around the failed prophecies the same way LDS scholars work around Joseph Smith’s failed prophecies (“delayed fulfillment,” “multiple/dual fulfillment,” “spiritual fulfillment,” “typological fulfillment,” “conditional fulfillment,” “prophetic telescoping,” “progressive revelation,” etc.)
Second, Galatians 1:8-9: “But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. As we said before, so say I now again, If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.” This seems to be a tailor-made argument against Mormonism, with Moroni and Joseph Smith taking the roles of “angel” and “man.” However, in context, Galatians 1:8 finds Paul warning the Galatians against those who taught that Gentile converts to Christianity were required to observe Mosaic Law, particularly circumcision, as a condition of full inclusion among God’s covenant people. This argument is further elaborated in chapters two and three. The appeal to Galatians isn’t without merit. Mormonism added layers of additional qualifications: priesthood ordination for men, temple endowment, temple sealing, and for some, the second anointing. LDS apologists will argue these are conditions of exaltation, which is different from salvation.
Third, and for our purposes, is 2 Nephi 25:23: “For we labor diligently to write, to persuade our children, and also our brethren, to believe in Christ, and to be reconciled to God; for we know that it is by grace that we are saved, after all we can do” (Emphasis added). I have seen this verse used in a wide array of anti-Mormon media: books, magazine articles, memes, AI-generated cartoon strips, etc. There is perhaps no other verse that raises the ire of Christians more than this one. They will contrast this verse with Ephesians 2:8-9: “For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast” (Emphasis added). Ephesians, along with the Pastorals (1 and 2 Timothy, Titus), 2 Colossians and 2 Thessalonians, is not considered and authentic Pauline epistle by the majority of critical scholars, but that doesn’t mean that Ephesians is necessarily wrong. It’s sound doctrine. At first glance, it appears we have a discrepancy between the soteriology of the Bible and the Book of Mormon.
We are going to dispel that notion.
THE BOOK OF MORMON AS A LITERARY WORK
We tend to view the Book of Mormon as primarily a theological work and secondarily as an historical work. These are both appropriate. However, we often overlook it as a literary work. As a literary work, it bears all the devices of classical literature, including the Bible. We find figurative language, such as metaphor, symbolism, hyperbole, and personification. We find narrative devices such as parable, allegory, irony, and allusion. We find poetic structures such as parallelism, chiasmus, and merism. Some LDS apologists are quick to point out chiasmus in the Book of Mormon as “evidence” of a Hebraic origin, but chiasmus as poetic form isn’t exclusive to Hebrew. It’s found in Greek, Latin, Ancient Near Eastern, and even modern literature.
There is another category that I believe is the most overlooked of all, idiom. As a purported English translation of an ancient text, the Book of Mormon is best understood in the English of 1830. The Book of Mormon itself makes this argument. Nephi wrote, “for [God] speaketh unto men according to their language, unto their understanding” (2 Nephi 31:8). Granted, today’s reader can read the Book of Mormon and understand it without any difficulty. But if we don’t understand the idioms of the early 1800s, some of the nuance can be lost or not fully understood. In worst-case scenarios, it can lead to faulty doctrines.
Even though the blog has been mostly quiet the last few years, I haven’t stopped doing research into the language of the Book of Mormon. I have been building a database of uniquely English idioms in the Book of Mormon that are not found in the Bible. As of now, I’ve collected nearly 200 entries covering various idiomatic categories, including religion, sermons, hymns, military, geography, philosophy, and poetry. Some of my favorites include “one eternal round” (which has nothing to do with multiple mortal probation or cycles of creation), “by the power of Him,” “point the finger of scorn,” “the wings of His spirit,” “a hiss and a byword,” “tears water my pillow,” “light unto the understanding” (which is far more profound than we realize), “thousands and tens of thousands” (don’t read that literally), “adieu,” and, of course, “after all we can do.” If Joseph Smith invented the Book of Mormon, he had an impressive command of the English language. And for the record, this isn’t evidence of plagiarism. Nor is it evidence that the Book of Mormon is a 19th century construction. It’s evidence of a shared linguistic reservoir the translation draws from.
John Tvedtnes pioneered the work of identifying Hebraisms in the Book of Mormon back in the early 1970s. I recently reviewed his work and found that all of the alleged Hebraisms in the Book of Mormon can be more easily be explained by, and identified as, Early Modern English (EME) idioms. This is what we should expect as an early 19th century translation. In fairness to Tvedtnes, we now have considerably more research tools at our disposal, such as Early English Books Online, Google Books/Ngram viewer, and the Oxford English Dictionary online. We can search keywords and phrases in these databases to see how they were used when the Book of Mormon was published. If you want to give it a try for yourself, click here. These are the results of my “after all we can do” query, with some examples posted below:
“..if we imagine that the temptations of the world and the devil are so strong, that we cannot possibly overcome them without such a powerful assistance of the holy spirit, as god has not annexed to the use of any ordinances or means of religion; if we imagine that the commandments of god are so impossible to be kept, that after all we can do, we must sit still in expectation of being converted suddenly by an irresistible grace; this must needs make all our Indeavours weak and faint, dead and without heart, and we shall certainly never be able to overcome our temptations and to persevere in well-doing: [.] # 3: it must indeed be confessed, that the 2 cor: 9:: corruption of our nature is really so great, that we can not do any thing as of our selves: it must be confessed, that the temptations of the world and the devil are really so strong, that we can never, meerly by our own strength, be able to stand and persevere unto the end: it must be confessed, that the commandment of god is so exceeding broad, that by all that we can do by our own power, we can never be justified…” (Samuel Clarke, 1599-1632)
“O My God, and my Father, increase the knowledge of thy Word, and the grace of thy Spirit in me. Enable me to perfect holiness in thy fear, and to hold fast the steadfastness of my hope unto the end. Pardon all the sins and errors of my life; and accept of my imperfect services through Jesus Christ. And because, though, after all we can do, we are unprofitable servants, thy infinite bounty will yet certainly recompense our sincere endeavours to promote thy glory; let me find any reward from thee; or rather do thou thyself vouchsafe to be my reward…” (Richard Lucas, “Religious Perfection.” 1704, London)
“PROPERLY speaking indeed, and in strict Justice, the most perfect Man up on Earth cannot be said to merit the very lowest Degree of Glory: The least Reward in Heaven will be an Happiness that is eternal; and there is no Proportion between an eternal Reward, and a short momentary Service, though it be that of the best Saints. Our Holiness itself, as well as that eternal Life, is the free Gift of God, and the good Actions we do, we thankfully ascribe to his assisting Grace; but though dare not presume to appeal to his Justice, we may, with an humble Confidence, rely upon his Mercy; though we cannot justly challenge any Reward from God, yet God, we know, will not forget our Work and Labour of Love; though our good Works are the Cause for the Sake of which, yet they are the Conditions, upon the Performance of which, we shall receive our Recompence; though after all we can do, we are still but unprofitable Servants, yet if we do all we can, we shall in no wise lose our Reward.” (Thomas Stackhouse, “A Compleat Body of Speculative and Practical Divinity,” 1743)
“Under this Head then I propose to illustrate and establish this great Doctrine of the Gospel, that by Grace we are saved, through Faith, and that not of ourselves, it is the Gift of GOD. As under the former Head I endeavoured to shew you, that before we can warrantably hope for Salvation, or the Blessedness of Heaven, there is a great deal necessary to be done on our part, I am now to shew you, that after all we can do, our Salvation is not to be ascribed to our own Works, but to divine Grace. (John Mason, The Lord’s Day, 1754)
“May the youthful reader of these pages be deeply impressed with a sense of the obligations to serve God in the morning of life. Think you that the service of a few short years, or perhaps days, of a life spent in folly, are a sufficient performance of duty, or a return to his mercies? Alas! after all we can do, we are but unprofitable servants.” (The Family Visiter and Sunday School Magazine, Volume X, 1829, General Protestant Episcopal Sunday School Union, NY)
“When we pray we should pray ‘with spirit and with understanding’ and the form which our Saviour taught us, should ever be the ground-work of all our petitions. Taught by him to feel our weakness and our wants, the depravity of our nature, and the deceitfulness of our hearts, we should not approach the throne of grace with self-assurance, nor tell, like the haughty Pharisee, of our alms and righteous deeds, as if we had something meritorious to offer to the divine acceptance; but knowing from our conscience, that ‘in many things we offend all I;’ and from Jesus Christ, in whom we trust, and who is all our salvation, that after all we can do, ‘we are unprofitable servants…’ (The Most Important Duties of the Christian Religions, A Collection of Sermons, Johnson Atkinson Busfeild, published 1818)
“There, young man, don’t you see the distinction between true and false righteousness? I need not tell you that God meeting him that worketh righteousness, is encouraging and rewarding it, and, in short, the very contrary from throwing the slur upon it, as in the next verse.
“I will not object to your explanation of this passage, sir: yet, after all we can do, are we not sinners in the sight of God?”
“Here I agree with you, my dear nephew, generally, for the best of us cannot be perfect; but do not call good evil.” “I do not mean it, sir, but only to shew that there is no merit in any thing that we can do, and that we must trust to Christ, and not to our own merits.” (“Gwelygordd, Or the Child of Sin: A Tale of Welsh Origin.” 1820, London.)
When we look at the above examples, we can plainly see that the sense of “after all we can do” is that no one can merit his or her own salvation. No matter what we do, no matter all our righteous deeds, we are all wholly dependent on Christ’s mercy. Nephi himself reiterated this chapters later, “And now, my beloved brethren, after ye have gotten into this strait and narrow path, I would ask if all is done? Behold, I say unto you, Nay; for ye have not come thus far save it were by the word of Christ with unshaken faith in him, relying wholly upon the merits of him who is mighty to save” (2 Nephi 31:19). If Nephi presumed that salvation was predicated on us exhausting our works to unlock grace, he’s contradicted himself. I don’t believe that’s the case.
Where the critics err is in assuming that “after all we can do” is successive rather than concessive. In other words, that salvation comes only after we have done a certain amount of works rather than that salvation comes through grace despite all of our works. Nephi “labored diligently” to teach his people to believe in Christ, and to be reconciled to God precisely because no amount of “works” can merit salvation. This is in perfect harmony with Ephesians 2:8-9 and the rest of the Book of Mormon.
Lehi said,
“Wherefore, how great the importance to make these things known unto the inhabitants of the earth, that they may know that there is no flesh that can dwell in the presence of God, it be through the merits, and mercy, and grace of the Holy Messiah…” (2 Nephi 2:8, emphasis added)
Jacob wrote,
“Wherefore, my beloved brethren, yourselves to the of God, and not to the will of the devil and the flesh; and remember, after ye are reconciled unto God, that it is only in and through the of God that ye are . Wherefore, may God you from death by the power of the resurrection, and also from everlasting death by the power of the , that ye may be received into the kingdom of God, that ye may praise him through grace divine. Amen” (2 Nephi 10:23-24, emphasis added).
We read that Aaron,
“…did expound unto [the King] the scriptures from the creation of Adam, laying the fall of man before him, and their carnal state and also the plan of redemption, which was prepared from the foundation of the world, through Christ, for all whosoever would believe on his name. And since man had fallen he could not merit anything of himself; but the sufferings and death of Christ atone for their sins, through faith and repentance, and so forth…” (Alma 22:13-14, emphasis added).
Samuel the Lamanite said,
“And if ye believe on his name ye will repent of all your sins, that thereby ye may have a remission of them through his merits” (Helaman 14:22, emphasis added).
Moroni wrote of the Nephite church,
“And after they had been received unto baptism, and were wrought upon and cleansed by the power of the Holy Ghost, they were numbered among the people of the church of Christ; and their names were taken, that they might be remembered and nourished by the good word of God, to keep them in the right way, to keep them continually watchful unto prayer, relying alone upon the merits of Christ, who was the author and the finisher of their faith” (Moroni 6:4, emphasis added)
Moroni then closed the Book of Mormon by writing,
“Yea, come unto Christ, and be perfected in him, and deny yourselves of all ungodliness; and if ye shall deny yourselves of all ungodliness, and love God with all your might, mind and strength, then is his grace sufficient for you, that by his grace ye may be perfect in Christ; and if by the grace of God ye are perfect in Christ, ye can in nowise deny the power of God. And again, if ye by the grace of God are perfect in Christ, and deny not his power, then are ye sanctified in Christ by the grace of God, through the shedding of the blood of Christ, which is in the covenant of the Father unto the remission of your sins, that ye become holy, without spot. (Moroni 10:22-23)
As evidenced by these passages, the only “work” required of us is repentance. God requires a broken heart and a contrite spirit. He requires us to be born again through the Holy Spirit. We are required to live a holy life of discipleship. We are required to bear the name of Christ. I don’t believe any mainstream Christian believes God saves the unrepentant. Even Ephesians states that salvation comes “by faith” through grace. The point is that regardless of our spiritual condition and our best efforts at discipleship, we are all reliant on Christ’s atonement, mercy, and grace. There is no disagreement between Paul and Nephi.
CONCLUSION
In recent months I have shared with Christians these historical examples of “after all we can do” and the various Book of Mormon passages showing that it is, in fact, solely because of Christ’s mercy that any of us are saved. I have been disappointed, but not surprised in the least, that despite all the evidence, it does not matter. Leon Festinger, who coined the term “cognitive dissonance,” wrote,
“A man with a conviction is a hard man to change. Tell him you disagree and he turns away. Show him facts or figures and he questions your sources. Appeal to logic and he fails to see your point. We have all experienced the futility of trying to change a strong conviction, especially if the convinced person has some investment in his belief.
“We are familiar with the variety of ingenious defenses with which people protect their convictions, managing to keep them unscathed through the most devastating attacks.
“But man’s resourcefulness goes beyond simply protecting a belief. Suppose an individual believes something with his whole heart; suppose further that he has a commitment to this belief, that he has taken irrevocable actions because of it; finally, suppose that he is presented with evidence, unequivocal and undeniable evidence, that his belief is wrong: what will happen? The individual will frequently emerge, not only unshaken, but even more convinced of the truth of his beliefs than ever before. Indeed, he may even show a new fervor about convincing and converting other people to his view.” (When Prophecy Fails, p.1)
Unfortunately, this is human nature. Most people will double down rather than acknowledge they were wrong. We should all strive to overcome this tendency because there is tremendous freedom in breaking free from the constraints of dogma in the pursuit of truth. In the case of spiritual matters, Alma said, “ is not to have a perfect knowledge of things; therefore if ye have faith ye for things which are seen, which are true” (Alma 32:21, emphasis added). I believe Christ is truth. I believe the Book of Mormon is truth. Both teach that salvation only comes through His grace.
As always, if I’ve gotten anything wrong, please let me know so I can correct it.
From day 1 Mormons have never let persecution discourage them. It’s all about knowing what is true.
LikeLike
Agreed. I hope they don’t lose that resilient spirit!
LikeLike
I love the quote you used in the conclusion. It is so apt to so many different circumstances. We really need to want to change, otherwise we will approach every situation with a mindset of, “How do I show how I am right, and they are wrong”. We can then ignore the obvious truth, even though we think we aren’t.
As far as who is a Christian, then I think it really doesn’t make sense to discuss that until their is a fix definition of what a Christian is. To be frank though, Mormons believe in a completely different Jesus. This Jesus is a fundamentally different person than mainstream Christians believe. He has a uniquely different role in the atonement (personal advancement), a uniquely different bodily form (permanent), and a uniquely different starting point (intelligence). In addition, in your previous post you said you interpreted the Bible according to the Book of Mormon, meaning the Book of Mormon is ahead of the Bible in your mind. Most Mormons would share this sentiment. According, to this, then I can see why Christians have a hard time accepting Mormons.
As far as “all we can do”, there are all sorts of things to be said about that. Sure, it is about grace. However, there has to be some kind of personal aspect as well. If it is all grace, then we are all saved regardless of what we do. If it is all grace, and some are conditionally saved, then God has to have some kind of metric to save us. This metric has to be based on individual actions, otherwise it would be arbitrary.
My opinion, is that God saves us all, regardless of what we do, however we need to have faith, as described in the Lectures on Faith, to improve ourselves and become more godly. This faith is simply believing there is a better way, and believing that God will help you find it. Once you do this, then you are exercising faith, and as a consequence you are being saved by the mercy of God.
I really don’t think anyone is ever permanently lost. We can call this atonement if we like. However, I think it is vastly more deep than that. This is the nature of God’s creation, and how God himself operates. Nothing is ever permanently lost, unless they want to be lost.
From the Gospel of Thomas:
Jesus said, “If your leaders tell you, ‘Look, the kingdom is in heaven,’ then the birds of heaven will precede you. If they tell you, ‘It’s in the sea,’ then the fish will precede you. Rather, the kingdom is within you and outside of you.
“When you know yourselves, then you’ll be known, and you’ll realize that you’re the children of the living Father. But if you don’t know yourselves, then you live in poverty, and you are the poverty.”
LikeLike
Fair points. I think it’s important to distinguish between the LDS Jesus and the Book of Mormon Jesus. They most definitely aren’t the same. The LDS Jesus is God’s spiritual and physical son, who became a God through obedience in the “pre-existence” and then volunteered to become the redeemer. The Book of Mormon Jesus is God Eternal who was and is from eternity to all eternity. Those two Jesus’ can’t co-exist.
And yes, I do agree that we have our part to play in salvation, but that it’s limited to faith and repentance, not the slew of extracurricular requirements the LDS church as added.
I agree that that all are saved from death. That’s a free gift of the Atonement to everyone. I’m less clear on what spiritual “salvation” looks like on the other side, other than nearness/separation from God. Maybe the Brother of Jared’s revelation has something to say about that. I’d sure like to know!
Thanks, as always, for stopping by!
LikeLike
Great article Matt! Dan Mcclellan did a you tube video entitled “Saved by grace after all we can do?” a couple years ago that goes right along with what you’re talking about. I believe he actually wrote a paper as well.
Sorry to hear about your stepfather. I was wondering why you hadn’t posted anything for awhile. It was good to see those new article notifications in my inbox. God bless!
LikeLike
Thanks much! I’m aware of Dan’s paper, but I deliberately didn’t read it. I wanted to do my own research on it. I actually wrote a draft for this years ago, but got distracted by other things, I guess. I was glad to get it done today. Hope all is well on your end.
LikeLiked by 1 person